Two police detectives at the 99th Precinct in Brooklyn, Jake and Amy are the epitome of opposites attract. Amy (Melissa Fumero) is a Type-A perfectionist with a love of pens and organization. Jake (Andy Samberg) is a man child who doesn’t pay his bills and has daddy issues. Watching them go from colleagues to friends to lovers is such a joy, and I truly appreciate that the show didn’t play around with an on-again-off-again relationship here. Once Jake and Amy committed, they committed.