Thursday Movie Picks: Amateur Sleuths
Wandering through the Shelves hosts a weekly movie challenge in which you choose 3-5 movies based on that Thursday’s theme and explain why you chose those movies.
Today's theme is Amateur Sleuths so here are my choices!
Lisbeth (The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo)
I think David Fincher's The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo is such an underrated movie. I read the book(s) and saw this in the theater and was blown away by the storytelling and Rooney Mara's fantastic portrayal of hacker Lisbeth Salander. She and disgraced journalist Mikael Blomkvist (Daniel Craig) come together to help solve a 40-year-old murder. There are no spoilers here, but Lisbeth Salander is a badass, and I am forever heartbroken that Fincher, Mara, and Craig didn't film the sequels.
Charley (Fright Night)
Okay, so this may be pushing the amateur-sleuth theme, but when Charley (Anton Yelchin, RIP) begins to suspect his neighbor, Jerry (a delicious Colin Farrell), is a vampire, he tries to uncover the truth before his girlfriend and mother become victims of the undead. I know this is a super hot take, and perhaps blasphemy, in horror-lover circles, but I enjoyed this remake so much more than the original. I thought Yelchin was wonderful as Charley, and Colin Farrell was so.... predatory and sexy as Jerry, and yes, I understand how messed up that sounds!
Stephanie (A Simple Favor)
A Simple Favor was a really pleasant surprise for me. I hadn't read the book, so I went in not really knowing what the movie was about. Stephanie (Anna Kendrick) is a single mother/vlogger who is befriended by Emily (Blake Lively), the mother of one of Stephanie's son's classmates. Emily is gorgeous and sophisticated, everything Stephanie admires. But Emily is also a mystery, and when she goes missing, Stephanie puts on her detective cap to try and figure out what happened to her new best friend. There are many twists and turns in this film, and Kenrick and Lively have fantastic chemistry. It doesn't hurt that Henry Golding plays Emily's husband (yummy).
14 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I don’t think Fright Night is a stretch at all. Charley is definitely an amateur sleuth. I liked this version well enough but I preferred the original 80’s version with Roddy McDowell and Chris Sarandon. It had a surer sense of humor.
I enjoyed Girl with the Dragon Tattoo when I saw it in the theatre but I’ve never had any desire to revisit it since. Good performances though.
I’ve heard of A Simple Favor but I’ve never made the time to watch because of my general aversion to Anna Kendrick. It sounds like a good fit.
I went with someone that probably pops into most peoples minds when they think about young girl detectives and two films I happened to see this past year that turned out to fit right into the theme.
Nancy Drew: Detective (1938)-A brief Warner Brothers series (this was followed by: Nancy Drew…Reporter, Nancy Drew…Trouble Shooter and Nancy Drew and the Hidden Staircase-all released in 1939) starring Oscar nominee Bonita Granville as the intrepid and curious young Nancy who sniffs trouble and cannot help investigating. That usually leads her into endless difficulties, but she always manages to solve the mystery in the end!
Hue and Cry (1947)- “The Blood and Thunder Boys” are a neighborhood group of kids in a partially bombed out section of post-WWII London. They suspect the boss of the village gang is directing his cohorts to their various criminal enterprises by manipulating stories in a popular kid’s paper “The Trump” (an actual kid comic of the time). Determined to stop the crooks they set out to solve the mystery of the leader’s identity and turn him over to the cops! Considered the first of the British Ealing comedies.
Who Killed Mary What’s ‘Er Name? (1971)-When a local prostitute is slain in a rough, rundown part of town, the police and neighbors react with little more than a shrug. Outraged, retired boxer Mickey Isador (Red Buttons), who knew the woman slightly, decides to try and find the killer. With the aid of his daughter, he pokes around the gritty dilapidated slum looking for answers, nearly getting himself offed in the process. Low-budget film captures the ramshackle decay that had infected many parts of New York City in the late 60’s/early 70’s.
Nancy Drew is a great choice and yes she was one of my first thoughts when I saw the theme! Nancy Drew and Scooby Doo. lol I’ve never heard of Hue and Cry or Who Killed Mary What’s ‘Er Name but I love the title. It sounds really fascinating.
These are really inspired picks, especially Charley in Fright Night!
Thank you! I think I’m due for a rewatch of Fright Night.
I have not seen the remake but I do love the original. The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo is so good with a great performance by Mara. It’s violent but I love it. I have not seen your last pick and not sure I will because I can’t get into Kendrick.
It took me a while to warm up to Anna Kendrick myself. She’s not my favorite but I enjoy her enough.
Hi Sara! I almost went with THE GIRL WITH THE DRAGON TATTOO! I like Fincher’s version with Rooney Mara who I agree is amazing here. I saw this version first actually, before the Swedish one, and I think both are really good. I like your third pick, but haven’t seen FRIGHT NIGHT. So sad about what happened to Anton Yelchin 🙁
I’m still depressed about Anton! Such a talent gone way too soon. I still want to watch the Swedish versions of The Dragon Tattoo films!
I still haven’t seen Fright Night (it’s on my list because of Colin) but the other two fits so well and they both are great films.
Thanks! I hope you enjoy Fright Night if and when you end up watching it. Really worth it for Colin alone!
Nice picks! The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo is amazing! It’s definitely one of Rooney’s best performances and Fincher’s best films. I hadn’t thought of A Simple Favor but Stephanie fits. Anna and Blake had chemistry, and their costumes were so much fun.
I feel like The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo is SO underrated! It deserves more love. A Simple Favor was so much better than I thought it would be.
Simple Favor – Skip the book. It is one of those rare instances where the movie is so much better.
good to know, thank you!