Below is a comprehensive list of accolades received by Widow's Bay. Feel free to contact me if I have missed any!

Year Organization Category Nominee(s) Result
2026Critics Choice AssociationBest Horror Series, Limited Series or Made-for-TV-MovieWidow's BayAnnounced on August 6, 2026
2026Critics Choice AssociationBest Actor in a Horror Series, Limited Series or Made-for-TV-MovieMatthew RhysAnnounced on August 6, 2026
2026Critics Choice AssociationBest Actress in a Horror Series, Limited Series or Made-for-TV-MovieKate O'FlynnAnnounced on August 6, 2026
2026Dorian TV AwardsBest TV ComedyWidow's BayAnnounced on August 15, 2026
2026Dorian TV AwardsBest TV Performance - ComedyMatthew RhysAnnounced on August 15, 2026
2026Dorian TV AwardsBest TV Supporting Performance - ComedyKate O'FlynnAnnounced on August 15, 2026
2026Fangoria Chainsaw AwardsBest SeriesWidow's BayAnnounced on October 25, 2026
2026IndieWire HonorsVisionary AwardKatie Dippold & Hiro MuraiHonored
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Comedy SeriesKatie Dippold, Hiro Murai, Carver Karaszewski, Claudia Shin, Matthew Rhys, Joanne Toll, Kelly Galuska, Mackenzie Dohr, Neil Casey, Colton Dunn, Kaitlin Waldron & Christian SprengerAnnounced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy SeriesMatthew RhysAnnounced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy SeriesStephen RootAnnounced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy SeriesDale DickeyAnnounced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy SeriesKate O'FlynnAnnounced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Directing for a Comedy SeriesHiro Murai (Welcome to Widow's Bay)Announced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Emmy AwardsOutstanding Writing for a Comedy SeriesKatie Dippold (Welcome to Widow's Bay)Announced September 14, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy SeriesHamish Linklater (Seasickness)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Guest Actress in a Comedy SeriesBetty Gilpin (Our History)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Casting for a Comedy SeriesAllison Jones, Emily Buntyn, Lisa Lobel, & Angela PeriAnnounced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Cinematography for a Series (Half-Hour)Christian Sprenger (Our History)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Music Composition for a Series (Original Dramatic Score)David Fleming (Our History)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Music SupervisionToko Nagata (for Beach Reads)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Picture Editing for a Single-Camera Comedy SeriesKyle Reiter (Welcome to Widow's Bay)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Picture Editing for a Single-Camera Comedy SeriesJen Bryson (What to Expect on Your Trip)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Picture Editing for a Single-Camera Comedy SeriesIsaac Hagy (Our History)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Production Design for a Narrative Program (Half-Hour)Steve Arnold, Peter Borck & Jennifer Engel (Lodging)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Sound Editing for a Comedy or Drama Series (Half-Hour) and AnimationMatt Yocum, Sang Kim, Goeun Everett, Ryan Sullivan, Nate Underkuffler, Leslie Bloome & Shaun Brennan (What to Expect on Your Trip)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Primetime Creative Emmy AwardsOutstanding Sound Mixing for a Comedy or Drama Series (Half-Hour) and AnimationTim Hoogenakker, Larry Benjamin, Kevin Parker, Scott Michael Smith, Judah Getz & Leslie Bloome (What to Expect on Your Trip)Announced September 5-6, 2026
2026Set Decorators Society of America AwardsBest Achievement in Décor/Design of a One Hour Contemporary SeriesJennifer Engel and Steve ArnoldAnnounced August 9, 2026
2026Television Critics Association AwardsProgram of the YearWidow's BayAnnounced Summer 2026
2026Television Critics Association AwardsOutstanding Achievement in ComedyWidow's BayAnnounced Summer 2026
2026Television Critics Association AwardsOutstanding New ProgramWidow's BayAnnounced Summer 2026
2026Television Critics Association AwardsIndividual Achievement in ComedyMatthew RhysAnnounced Summer 2026
2026Television Critics Association AwardsIndividual Achievement in ComedyKaye O'FlynnAnnounced Summer 2026